9 Best Newborn Pacifiers for 2024: Safe, Comfortable, and Stylish Options

9 Best Newborn Pacifiers for 2024: Safe, Comfortable, and Stylish Options

Finding the perfect pacifier for your newborn can feel like a daunting task. With so many options on the market, each claiming to be the best, it’s hard to know which one will truly soothe your little one. You want something safe, comfortable, and effective, but where do you start?

In this article, we’ve narrowed down the choices to the 9 best newborn pacifiers available today. Whether you’re a first-time parent or looking to upgrade from your current pacifier, our list will help you make an informed decision. Dive in and discover which pacifier will bring comfort and calm to your baby.

Types of Newborn Pacifiers

Navigating the world of pacifiers can be overwhelming. Knowing the types helps you make an informed choice for your baby’s comfort and health.

Orthodontic Pacifiers

Orthodontic pacifiers support your baby’s developing mouth structure. These pacifiers are designed with a flattened bottom and rounded top to mimic the shape of a mother’s nipple during breastfeeding. Examples include the Philips Avent Soothie and Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature. Using orthodontic pacifiers can help prevent dental issues and promote healthy oral development. Choose a brand known for its quality and safety to ensure your baby gets the best.

Feeding-Shaped Pacifiers

Feeding-shaped pacifiers resemble the shape of a bottle nipple to facilitate easier transitions between breastfeeding and bottle feeding. These pacifiers, like the Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci and Nuk Newborn Orthodontic, are ideal if you’re both breastfeeding and formula feeding. Their unique shape helps prevent nipple confusion, making feeding times smoother for you and your baby. Always look for BPA-free options for maximum safety.

Considerations for Selecting a Newborn Pacifier

When choosing a newborn pacifier, several crucial factors ensure your baby’s safety and comfort.

Material Safety

Prioritize pacifiers made from BPA-free materials to avoid harmful chemicals. Look for pacifiers crafted from medical-grade silicone or natural rubber, which are both hypoallergenic and durable. Popular brands like Philips Avent and Nuk often provide these safe options for newborns.

Size and Shape

Ensure the pacifier’s size and shape match your baby’s age and developmental stage. A newborn pacifier should have a small, orthodontic nipple to support oral development. For instance, brands like Tommee Tippee and Dr. Brown’s offer specifically designed options to fit comfortably in a newborn’s mouth.


Opt for pacifiers with proper ventilation holes to prevent choking and skin irritation. These holes allow air to circulate, reducing the risk of rashes and ensuring overall safety. For example, designs from brands like Tommee Tippee and Nuk incorporate well-placed holes to keep babies safe and comfortable.

1. Best Overall Newborn Pacifier

When looking for the best overall newborn pacifier, you want something that combines comfort, safety, and effectiveness. The top choice that meets these criteria is the Philips Avent Soothie.

Features and Benefits

The Philips Avent Soothie stands out due to its unique design and high-quality materials. It’s made from medical-grade silicone, ensuring it’s BPA-free and safe for your infant. The one-piece construction helps prevent breakage and reduces choking hazards. Its shape supports the natural development of your baby’s teeth and gums, making it a perfect orthodontic option. The pacifier also has ventilation holes, increasing breathability and decreasing skin irritation.

User Reviews

Parents rave about the Philips Avent Soothie’s ability to calm their newborns instantly. Many highlight the durability of the silicone material, noting that it withstands repeated sterilization without losing its shape. Users appreciate the pacifier’s design, mentioning that it seamlessly fits into their baby’s mouth, soothing them quickly. Reviews frequently mention fewer instances of colic and fussiness, attributing this to the comfort provided by the Soothie.

2. Best Orthodontic Newborn Pacifier

Features and Benefits

The Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier stands out as the best orthodontic option. It’s designed to support the natural shape of your baby’s developing palate, gums, and teeth. Made from medical-grade silicone, it’s BPA-free and hypoallergenic, ensuring safety and hygiene for your infant. The symmetrical orthodontic shape ensures the pacifier is always right-side-up, which helps reduce the risk of dental issues.

The pacifier also features a soft, skin-like texture that feels comforting for your baby. Its curved shield with large ventilation holes prevents skin irritation by allowing air to circulate. The lightweight design makes it easier for newborns to keep the pacifier in their mouths for longer periods. These features collectively provide comfort, safety, and support for oral development.

User Reviews

Parents who have chosen this pacifier applaud its effectiveness in soothing their babies. Many mention that their little ones took to the Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier quickly, providing them much-needed relief. Several users also appreciate the durable construction, noting that the pacifiers withstand frequent sterilizations without losing their shape or texture.

Positive feedback highlights the importance of the orthodontic design in maintaining good oral health, with some parents noting a visible reduction in potential dental issues. Overall, this pacifier has received extensive praise for its thoughtful design and reliable performance, making it a favorite among many families.

3. Best Silicone Newborn Pacifier

Silicone pacifiers are incredibly popular due to their durability and ease of cleaning.

Features and Benefits

Safety tops the list of features for the best silicone pacifier. Made from medical-grade silicone, these pacifiers are free from BPA and other harmful chemicals, ensuring your baby’s health. Comfort is another key benefit; silicone is gentle on a newborn’s sensitive skin, reducing the risk of irritation. Their one-piece design prevents choking hazards, and they often have ventilation holes to enhance airflow, preventing skin rashes.

User Reviews

User reviews frequently highlight the long-lasting nature of silicone pacifiers. Parents love that they can be sterilized repeatedly without degrading. Many commend the soothing effect these pacifiers have on their babies, often noting that the consistent use helps in establishing a calming routine. One popular brand receives praise for its ergonomic design that fits perfectly in a baby’s mouth, enhancing the overall soothing experience.

4. Best Natural Rubber Newborn Pacifier

Choosing a natural rubber pacifier offers a more eco-friendly and safe option for your baby. Natural rubber is known for its softness and flexibility, making it a comfortable choice for newborns.

Features and Benefits

  1. Eco-Friendly Material
    Natural rubber is a sustainable resource, reducing your environmental impact. It’s biodegradable, unlike synthetic materials, adding to its eco-friendly benefits. Brands like Natursutten offer pacifiers made from 100% natural rubber that are free from harmful chemicals.
  2. Soft and Flexible
    The softness of natural rubber mimics the feel of a mother’s breast, providing comfort and soothing for your baby. Its flexibility ensures that it won’t harm the baby’s developing gums and teeth.
  3. Hypoallergenic and Safe
    Natural rubber pacifiers are often hypoallergenic, making them a suitable choice for babies with sensitive skin. They’re free from BPA, phthalates, and PVC, ensuring your baby isn’t exposed to harmful substances.
  4. Durable Design
    Despite being soft, natural rubber is durable and can withstand the pressure of sucking. These pacifiers maintain their shape and integrity over time, offering long-lasting use.
  1. Soothing Effect
    Parents have praised the natural rubber pacifier for its calming effect on their babies. The soft, skin-like texture helps in reducing fussiness and promoting better sleep.
  2. Easy to Clean
    Many users appreciate how easy it is to clean natural rubber pacifiers. You can sterilize them with boiling water without worrying about material degradation.
  3. Loved by Babies
    Reviews indicate that infants quickly get accustomed to the natural rubber pacifiers due to their comforting feel. Parents reported fewer instances of their baby rejecting the pacifier compared to silicone alternatives.
  4. Eco-Conscious Choice
    Environmentally conscious parents particularly value the sustainability aspect. They feel good knowing the pacifier is biodegradable and safe for their baby and the planet.

Overall, the natural rubber pacifier offers a blend of comfort, safety, and eco-friendliness, making it an excellent choice for conscientious parents. Brands like Natursutten lead the way in providing high-quality, natural rubber pacifiers that meet these needs.

5. Best for Breastfed Babies

Features and Benefits

Choosing the right pacifier for breastfed babies can help ensure a smooth transition and maintain breastfeeding routines. Look for pacifiers designed to mimic the natural feel and shape of a nipple. These options offer a more seamless experience for babies who switch between breastfeeding and pacifier use, reducing nipple confusion.

Key features include an orthodontic design that supports oral development and BPA-free materials like medical-grade silicone or natural rubber. The pacifiers often have a symmetrical shape, ensuring consistent sucking, whether right side up or down. Examples of top choices in this category are the MAM Newborn Pacifier and the Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier.

User Reviews

Parents of breastfed babies often rave about the natural transition provided by these pacifiers. Many mention how their babies easily accept the pacifiers without any disruption to breastfeeding. Reviews highlight brands like MAM and Tommee Tippee for their effective designs that mimic the breast, soft textures, and durability. Users also appreciate the pacifiers’ ability to soothe their babies while maintaining consistent nursing patterns. For instance, moms frequently endorse the MAM Newborn Pacifier, praising its ergonomic shape that encourages natural sucking behavior and its durability through multiple sterilizations.

6. Best Budget-Friendly Newborn Pacifier

When you’re on a budget, finding a high-quality pacifier that won’t break the bank is essential. The best budget-friendly newborn pacifier combines affordability with key features that prioritize your baby’s comfort and safety.

Features and Benefits

Affordable pacifiers don’t skimp on crucial features. Budget-friendly options are made from BPA-free materials to ensure your baby’s safety. Many use medical-grade silicone for durability and easy cleaning. Ventilation holes are standard to prevent skin irritation, and orthodontic designs support proper oral development. Examples include brands like First Years and Nuby, offering ergonomic shapes and easy-to-grip handles.

User Reviews

Parents love budget-friendly pacifiers for their value without compromising quality. Many reviews highlight their durability, even with frequent sterilizations. Users appreciate the soft, silicone material providing comfort for newborns. Ventilation holes get positive mentions for preventing rashes and skin irritation. Plus, parents find that these budget options are just as effective in soothing their babies as pricier alternatives, making them a win-win for families.

7. Best Airflow Newborn Pacifier

Features and Benefits

Choose the best airflow newborn pacifier to ensure your baby stays comfortable and rash-free. These pacifiers have larger ventilation holes that improve airflow around the mouth, reducing moisture build-up. The MAM Air Pacifier is a top choice; it’s made of BPA-free silicone and features a symmetrical nipple that supports natural jaw development. The lightweight design also makes it easier for babies to keep in their mouths.

User Reviews

Parents rave about airflow pacifiers for keeping their baby’s skin dry. The MAM Air Pacifier receives high marks for its breathable design and comfort. Many reviews highlight the reduced occurrence of skin irritation and the ease of cleaning. Users appreciate the durability and how their babies take to this pacifier quickly.

8. Best Nighttime Newborn Pacifier

Nighttime pacifiers can significantly improve your baby’s sleep experience. They come with unique features designed to soothe your baby through the night.

Features and Benefits

Choose a nighttime newborn pacifier with features like BPA-free materials and orthodontic design. Look for options with a soft, silicone nipple that mimics the natural feel to help your baby sleep comfortably. Also, check the pacifier size to ensure it fits your newborn correctly, preventing any choking hazard. Pacifiers like the Tommee Tippee Night Time Pacifier are designed to support oral development while ensuring safety and comfort.

Glow-in-the-Dark Functionality

A glow-in-the-dark pacifier can be a game-changer during those midnight soothing sessions. Pacifiers with this feature make it easy to locate them in a dark room without turning on the lights and disturbing your baby’s sleep. For example, the MAM Night Pacifier glows softly in the dark, providing you convenience and making nights calmer for both you and your little one.

9. Most Stylish Newborn Pacifier

Looking for a pacifier that combines functionality with style? The Most Stylish Newborn Pacifier is designed to add a trendy touch without compromising on the essential features your baby needs.

Features and Benefits

Offers modern design elements that set it apart from traditional pacifiers. Made with medical-grade silicone, it’s both safe and durable. The orthodontic nipple shape supports healthy oral development. It includes ventilation holes to reduce skin irritation, ensuring your baby remains comfortable. With a range of chic colors and patterns, this pacifier is perfect for style-conscious parents. Easy to clean and dishwasher-safe, it offers convenience on busy days.

User Reviews

Parents rave about the aesthetic appeal of this pacifier. They love its stylish look and appreciate that it doesn’t compromise on safety or comfort. Many mention that their babies took to it quickly and seemed soothed. Some reviews highlight how well it maintains its quality after multiple washes. The trendy designs receive frequent compliments from family and friends, making it a popular choice among new parents.


Choosing the right pacifier for your newborn is essential for their comfort and safety. With various options available, from the highly recommended Philips Avent Soothie to the stylish and durable choices, you can find the perfect fit for your baby. Consider factors like material, shape, and ventilation to ensure your little one gets the best experience. Whether you prioritize orthodontic designs, eco-friendly materials, or budget-friendly options, there’s a pacifier out there to meet your needs. Make an informed decision and give your newborn the soothing comfort they deserve.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *