9 Best True Crime Podcasts You Need to Listen to Right Now

If you’re a true crime enthusiast, you’re not alone. The genre has exploded in popularity, with countless podcasts diving deep into real-life mysteries, unsolved cases, and gripping criminal investigations. Whether you’re commuting, working out, or just relaxing at home, a compelling true crime podcast can turn any moment into a suspenseful experience.

But with so many options out there, how do you find the best ones? We’ve done the legwork for you and compiled a list of the 9 best true crime podcasts that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Get ready to uncover the most intriguing stories and dive into the dark underbelly of human nature.

Criteria for Choosing the Best Podcasts

When selecting the best true crime podcasts, it’s crucial to consider several factors that contribute to a compelling and engaging experience.

Storytelling Quality

Engaging storytelling is a must in any true crime podcast. Look for well-crafted narratives that captivate you from the first episode. High-quality podcasts weave intricate plotlines with clear, concise delivery, maintaining suspense without unnecessary filler.

Authenticity and Research Depth

Authentic content with thorough research is vital. Choose podcasts that provide well-researched cases, using credible sources. These podcasts often include interviews with experts or people directly involved in the case, adding layers of authenticity and depth.

Host Engagement and Expertise

Engaging hosts with expertise in the subject matter elevate the listening experience. Opt for podcasts with hosts who have a background in law enforcement, journalism, or criminology. Their insights and engaging delivery can make complex cases easier to understand and more intriguing.

Top 9 Best True Crime Podcasts

Ready to dive into some captivating true crime podcasts? We’ve curated a list of the top 9 that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Critical Reception and Listener Reviews

1. Serial: Serial’s first season captivated millions, making it one of the most talked-about true crime podcasts. With a rating of 4.5 stars on Apple Podcasts and countless positive reviews, it’s a favorite among true crime enthusiasts.
2. My Favorite Murder: With a dedicated fanbase known as “Murderinos,” this podcast boasts an impressive 4.7-star rating. Listeners love the blend of humor and horror presented by hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark.
3. Criminal: Praised for its storytelling and unique cases, Criminal holds a 4.6-star rating. Host Phoebe Judge’s soothing voice and in-depth research make it a must-listen.
4. Casefile: Known for its meticulous research and gripping narrative, Casefile enjoys a 4.8-star rating. Listeners appreciate the anonymous host’s straightforward storytelling style.
5. Sword and Scale: This podcast dives deep into the depravity of human nature, earning a 4.5-star rating. It’s known for its graphic content and detailed case analysis.
6. Up and Vanished: This serialized investigative podcast has rave reviews for its compelling storytelling, holding a 4.4-star rating. Host Payne Lindsey’s dedication to solving cold cases is evident in every episode.
7. Sword and Scale: This podcast dives deep into the depravity of human nature, earning a 4.5-star rating. It’s known for its graphic content and detailed case analysis.
8. Someone Knows Something: With its meticulous investigative journalism, this podcast has a 4.4-star rating. David Ridgen’s empathetic approach resonates with listeners.
9. Wine & Crime: Infusing humor with true crime, this podcast enjoys a 4.6-star rating. Listeners love the hosts’ witty banter and deep dives into different criminal cases.

1. Serial: Debuted the serialized storytelling format in podcasting, creating a cultural phenomenon. It’s known for deep dives into one case per season, with meticulous attention to detail.
2. My Favorite Murder: Combines comedy and true crime, making it stand out. The hosts’ candid chatter creates a unique, engaging experience.
3. Criminal: Focuses on less-known cases with unusual angles. Each episode is standalone, allowing you to pick and choose as you please.
4. Casefile: Features anonymous narration, allowing you to focus solely on the story. Each episode is thoroughly researched, often involving lesser-known cases.

Serial: Pioneering the Genre

“Serial” stands as a groundbreaking true crime podcast that redefined the genre.

Overview of the Serial Podcast

Launched in 2014 by Sarah Koenig and Julie Snyder, “Serial” dives into a single story over multiple episodes. Season 1, which investigates the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee, gained massive popularity. Each season explores different cases, bringing exhaustive research and compelling storytelling. The podcast’s narrative style keeps you hooked, blending investigative journalism with human interest.

Impact on True Crime Podcasting

“Serial” revolutionized podcasting, drawing millions of listeners and mainstream media attention. Its success demonstrated the potential of serialized storytelling in audio formats. It inspired countless other true crime podcasts, shaping content creation standards. Platforms like Slate and The Guardian praised “Serial,” cementing its place as a benchmark in the genre.

Crime Junkie: Focused Storytelling

“Crime Junkie,” hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, stands out for its gripping and detailed storytelling.

Format and Structure of Crime Junkie

Every episode of “Crime Junkie” is meticulously crafted, typically lasting around 30 to 60 minutes. Ashley narrates most of the story while Brit adds engaging commentary, making it dynamic. Each episode covers a single case, often involving lesser-known crimes, providing a fresh angle. The podcast wisely skips unnecessary embellishments, jumping straight into the facts. Frequent use of cliffhangers and suspenseful music heightens intrigue, ensuring you stay hooked from start to finish.

Key Episodes to Listen To

Several episodes of “Crime Junkie” are must-listens:

1. “MISSING: Maura Murray” – Delve into the mysterious disappearance of Maura Murray, a case filled with perplexing twists and turns.
2. “MURDERED: Laci Peterson” – Explore the tragic story of Laci Peterson’s murder, a case that captivated national attention.
3. “WANTED: Killer on the High Bridge” – Engage with the ongoing investigation into the shocking murders of two young girls in Delphi, Indiana.
4. “CONSPIRACY: The Women of Juárez” – Examine the chilling patterns of femicides in Ciudad Juárez and the potential cover-ups involved.

These episodes not only showcase the podcast’s narrative prowess but also highlight its commitment to bringing lesser-known cases to light.

Sword and Scale: Pushing Boundaries

Themes and Controversies

“Sword and Scale” tackles unsettling real-life criminal cases, often diving into grisly details and psychological factors behind them. Episodes feature unsettling themes like brutal murders, serial killers, and disturbing 911 calls. Host Mike Boudet isn’t afraid to push boundaries, which has led to both acclaim and controversy. The podcast has faced criticism for its graphic content and Boudet’s occasionally provocative commentary. Despite these controversies, “Sword and Scale” maintains a solid listenership due to its deep investigation and immersive storytelling.

Why It Stands Out

“Sword and Scale” stands out for its in-depth exploration of crime and the human psyche. Boudet’s thorough research and presentation captivate you from the first minute. Episodes often combine expert interviews, actual audio footage, and dramatic narrations, creating a compelling atmosphere. This podcast offers a mix of popular and obscure cases, ensuring you always find something intriguing. High production quality and bold content choices make “Sword and Scale” an unforgettable true crime experience.

My Favorite Murder: Combining Comedy and Crime

For a unique take on true crime, “My Favorite Murder” blends humor with real-life stories, offering a refreshing perspective.

Balancing Humor with Seriousness

Hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark expertly mix laughter with crime stories. They often use humor to lighten the mood without diminishing the gravity of the subjects. By balancing jokes and serious commentary, they create an engaging experience that keeps you interested in even the darkest tales.

Community and Fan Base

“My Favorite Murder” boasts a dedicated following, known as “Murderinos.” This community is active on social media, engaging in discussions, sharing theories, and even meeting up at live events. By fostering a sense of belonging, the podcast has built a loyal and interactive fan base that feels like a family.

The Last Podcast on the Left: A Blend of Horror and Crime

The Last Podcast on the Left” stands out for its unique combination of horror and true crime. Hosted by Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, and Henry Zebrowski, the show offers a unique blend of deep research and dark humor.

Dive into Different Realms of True Crime and Horror

Exploring a wide array of topics, this podcast takes you through notorious serial killers, unsolved mysteries, and paranormal events. Covering both chilling crimes and supernatural occurrences, the hosts deliver in-depth analyses that keep you engaged. Their expertise in true crime and their comedic approach create a unique listening experience that’s both informative and entertaining.

Notable Episodes

Check out standout episodes like their deep dive into the life of Ted Bundy or the multi-part series on the Jonestown cult. These episodes showcase their ability to combine meticulous research with engaging storytelling. They also tackle lesser-known cases, adding a fresh perspective to the true crime genre.

Casefile: Anonymous Narration

Presentation Style

Narrated by an anonymous host, “Casefile” differs from other true crime podcasts with its straightforward and unembellished delivery. The lack of personal commentary keeps the focus squarely on the details of each case, making for a purely factual listening experience. This unique approach allows listeners to form their own opinions based solely on the presented evidence and witness accounts.

Memorable Cases Covered

“Casefile” has covered numerous high-profile and lesser-known cases with the same meticulous attention to detail. Noteworthy episodes include the chilling story of the “Golden State Killer” and the mysterious case of “Tamám Shud,” also known as the Somerton Man. The thorough research and comprehensive storytelling ensure that each episode is both informative and deeply engaging for true crime enthusiasts.

Criminal: Philosophical and Reflective Angles

“Criminal” takes a unique angle, diving into the broader philosophical and reflective aspects of crime. It’s hosted by Phoebe Judge, who brings a distinctive, thoughtful approach to storytelling.

Approach to Crime Storytelling

Judge presents each episode with a calm, reflective tone, allowing you to delve deeper into the moral and ethical dilemmas surrounding each case. Instead of focusing solely on the gory details, “Criminal” explores the human stories behind the crimes, often leaving you contemplating larger societal issues. This approach makes the podcast stand out, providing a contemplative listening experience.

Highlights From the Podcast

Episodes like “Call Your Mom” and “The Paper Route” showcase the podcast’s unique storytelling method. “Call Your Mom” reflects on the impact of a murder on a small community, while “The Paper Route” delves into the haunting mystery of an unsolved child abduction. These episodes are prime examples of how “Criminal” elevates the true crime genre by blending facts with philosophical questions, offering you a richer, more nuanced understanding of the cases.

Someone Knows Something: Investigative Journalism

“Someone Knows Something,” hosted by David Ridgen, dives into cold cases with a deeply investigative approach. You’ll be captivated by Ridgen’s meticulous methods and gripping storytelling.

Impact of Investigative Techniques

Ridgen’s thorough investigative techniques bring fresh perspectives to unsolved cases. By interviewing key witnesses, revisiting crime scenes, and uncovering hidden evidence, Ridgen brings you closer to the truth. For instance, his methodical examination in the disappearance of Adrien McNaughton is a prime example of the show’s compelling investigative work.

Engaging Unsolved Cases

“Someone Knows Something” covers intriguing unsolved cases that keep you hooked. From mysterious disappearances to puzzling crime scenes, each episode promises a deep dive into the enigma, often igniting new leads and public interest. Notable episodes like “Sheryl Sheppard” and “Greavette” combine personal stories with investigative rigor, making you feel part of the search for answers.

Up and Vanished: Solving Real Mysteries

Achievements in Reopening Cold Cases

Payne Lindsey’s “Up and Vanished” is renowned for its success in reopening cold cases. The podcast famously brought renewed attention to the 2005 disappearance of Tara Grinstead. This investigative series played a pivotal role in producing new leads and eventually led to the arrest of two suspects. Your interest in uncovering real mysteries makes this podcast an essential listen. By spotlighting forgotten cases, it reignites public interest and prompts legal authorities to take action.

Success Stories and Key Insights

Experience gripping success stories like Tara Grinstead’s case, where the podcast’s efforts directly contributed to solving the mystery. You’ll find Lindsey’s detailed analysis and engaging storytelling uncover hidden angles and overlooked evidence. His ability to gain the trust of witnesses and officials results in exclusive insights. For example, through meticulous interviews and dogged persistence, “Up and Vanished” turns silence into leads, and inquiries into arrests. If you’re captivated by real success in solving crimes, this podcast is a must-add to your playlist.

Conclusion: Your True Crime Journey

Embarking on your true crime podcast journey offers a unique blend of suspense, intrigue, and real-world mystery. These podcasts provide not only captivating stories but also deep dives into human psychology and societal issues. Whether you’re drawn to the meticulous details of high-profile cases or the philosophical questions surrounding crime, there’s a podcast tailored to your interests. Dive in, and you’ll find yourself not just entertained but also more informed about the complexities of true crime.